Facebook pixel
new boiler

Get a new boiler

Fixed price boilers, next day

See boiler prices
new air conditioning

Air Conditioning

Get a quote
new heat pump

Heat Pumps

Coming soon

new ev charger

EV Chargers

Get a quote
boiler servicing

Boiler Servicing

Get a quote

Last updated: 8th August, 2023


Repair or Replace Broken Boiler?

Repair or Replace Broken Boiler?

Key takeaways

  • Recognising signs of a faulty boiler is essential for timely repairs or replacement.
  • Decisions to repair or replace should consider efficiency and environmental impact.
  • Modern boilers offer increased longevity, efficiency, and safety features over older systems.

Deciding whether to repair or replace a broken boiler can be daunting. Our blog 'Repair or Replace Broken Boiler? Top Reasons Why Modern Boilers Outshine the Rest' navigates you through this complex decision, weighing up the pros and cons of boiler repair and boiler replacement.

Dealing with a broken boiler can be a daunting experience for homeowners. The dilemma of whether to repair or replace the appliance is often a key concern. 

Understanding the intricacies of modern boilers and the advantages they offer can play a significant role in making an informed decision.

Need a new boiler?

Get a quote in 60 seconds, fitted as fast as next day!
0% APR finance available.

Get a quote

Boilers are the heart of a home's central heating system, providing both warmth and hot water. With ever-evolving advancements in technology, modern boilers offer improved efficiency, longevity, and environmentally friendly features, outshining their older counterparts. 

Recognising the signs that your boiler requires attention and assessing the potential downsides of an ageing system are crucial steps in deciding whether repairing or replacing the boiler presents a more viable, cost-effective solution.

Understanding Boilers

Boilers play a crucial role in providing heating and hot water to homes and buildings. As technology advances, modern boilers have become more efficient, reliable, and environmentally friendly. In this section, we will discuss different types of boilers and the benefits of modern, A-rated boilers.

Types of Boilers

There are various types of boilers, each with its own advantages and suitable applications. The primary categories of boilers include:

Boiler Types


Combis or combination boilers, combine all components and aspects of a heating system (central heating and hot water production) into one succinct and powerful unit.

Their economic size, quick flow rates and dual functionality means combis are extremely efficient and effective when heating a multitude of property sizes, being best suited for small to medium sized homes with 1-2 bathrooms.

Check out our guide to the Best Combi Boilers!

Get a quote


System boilers perform best in homes with a high hot water demand, specifically either larger properties with a higher number of residents or properties with two or more bathrooms. 

System boilers store hot water in a separate cylinder which provides constant flow access but requires additional (minimal) storage space.

System boilers can service multiple flow outlets at one time, meaning no one in a larger home would be standing around waiting for a shower.

Get a quote

Heat Only

A heat only boiler provides the heat for a home's central heating system and hot water cylinder. A heat only boiler is suited to servicing larger properties with multiple bathrooms/radiators or a business premises with a high water demand. 

Heat only boilers do require sufficient installation space within a property, as they use two storage tanks (feed & expansion) as well as the aforementioned hot water cylinder. 

Although a combi is generally considered more space saving, a modern heat only boiler is still compact and can supply more bathrooms with hot running water than a combi can. 

Get a quote

Modern boilers offer various benefits over their older counterparts. Such advantages include:

  1. Energy Efficiency: Modern boilers, especially A-rated and condensing types, can achieve efficiencies of 90% or higher, contributing to significant energy savings and reduced heating bills.

  2. Lower Emissions: High-efficiency boilers produce fewer emissions and contribute to reduced carbon footprints. This aspect is beneficial for the environment and helps combat climate change.

  3. Better Heating Control: Today's boilers are equipped with advanced controls that allow users to manage their heating systems effectively and efficiently, providing optimum comfort and energy savings.

  4. Compact Design: Modern boilers come in compact sizes, making them suitable for installation in smaller spaces such as lofts, cupboards, and tight corners.

  5. Longevity: Built with high-quality materials and components, modern boilers are designed to be more reliable and durable, reducing the need for repairs and replacements over time.


In conclusion, modern boilers offer a range of benefits that make them a supreme choice for heating and hot water systems. Their high efficiency, reduced emissions, and advanced features ensure that homeowners can enjoy long-lasting, reliable, and environmentally friendly heating solutions.

Signs Your Boiler Needs Attention

Boilers are crucial for providing heat and hot water in your home. Just like any other appliance, boilers need regular maintenance and attention to ensure they function efficiently. Below are some warning signs you should look out for that indicate your boiler may need some attention:

  • Unusual noises: Banging, tapping, clicking, or knocking sounds coming from your boiler could indicate a fault within the central heating system or a problem with the boiler itself. Don't ignore these noises, as they can lead to more significant issues if left unaddressed.

  • No hot water or heat: If your radiators don't heat up, or you're not getting any hot water from the taps, it might be time to call a professional heating engineer to diagnose and fix the issue.

  • Boiler pressure fluctuations: Boilers operate at a specific pressure for optimal performance. If you notice sudden drops or increases in pressure, it could be an indication that there is a problem with your boiler or central heating system.

  • Leaks: Leaking boilers can cause damage to your property and also signify a malfunctioning component. Always investigate any visible leaks or drips, and consider calling an engineer to address the issue.

  • Carbon monoxide warning: If you or someone in your household experiences dizziness, stomach pain, or shortness of breath, you should seek medical attention and have a professional inspect your boiler. These symptoms could indicate a potentially dangerous carbon monoxide leak.

Regular boiler maintenance and inspections can help to avoid these issues with your boiler.

However, if you encounter any of the warning signs above, it is essential to call in an expert heating engineer to assess the problem. They may recommend repairing or replacing your boiler, ensuring that your home stays warm and comfortable, and your boiler remains efficient and safe to use.


Repair or Replace Decision Making

When dealing with a broken boiler, one of the main decisions that need to be made is whether to repair it or replace it with a newer model. This decision ultimately depends on a few key factors, such as the boiler's age, cost of repairs, warranty, and availability of parts and labour.

The age of the boiler plays a significant role in the choice of repair or replace. Older boilers tend to be less efficient and have a higher likelihood of breakdowns than their modern counterparts.

As a general rule, if the boiler is more than 10 years old and experiencing regular faults, it may be more cost-effective to consider a replacement.

The cost of repairing a boiler can vary greatly, depending on the nature of the issue and the availability of parts.

Common replacement parts include gas valves, fans, printed circuit boards, and heat exchangers. It is important to research the specific parts that may be needed for your boiler and to factor in the cost of labour when making a decision. In some cases, a one-off repair can prove to be more affordable than a full replacement.

However, frequent call-outs and accumulated call-out charges may eventually outweigh the benefits of repairing the boiler.

A crucial aspect to consider is the warranty or insurance that comes with your boiler. If the boiler is still under warranty, the cost of repairs or even full replacement may be covered by the manufacturer.

In such cases, opting for repair or replacement through the warranty would be a more financially sensible option.

Labour costs can widely vary based on location and the complexity of the repair needed. Some companies may offer fixed price repairs, while others might charge by the hour. It's essential to obtain quotes from multiple service providers before making a decision to ensure you're getting a fair deal.

While modern boilers have clear advantages in terms of efficiency and reliability, the decision to repair or replace a broken boiler comes down to a careful evaluation of factors like age, repair costs, warranty coverage, and labour rates.

By considering these aspects, homeowners can make a well-informed decision that will keep their homes warm and cosy with minimal stress on the wallet.

Benefits of Modern Boilers

Modern boilers offer a range of advantages to homeowners and businesses alike. From improved energy efficiency to enhanced safety features, these contemporary heating systems provide many reasons to consider investing in a new boiler.

One primary benefit of modern boilers is their high energy efficiency. Newer models are designed to convert a higher percentage of fuel into useful heat for your home or business, which can result in significant savings on your energy bills. This efficiency also contributes to reducing carbon emissions, making a new boiler a more environmentally friendly choice.

When it comes to performance, modern boilers deliver consistent hot water and heating to your radiators. Combined with the latest thermostat controls, you can enjoy precise temperature management throughout your entire property.

This level of control not only ensures a comfortable living or working environment but also prevents wasting energy on overheating rooms.

Safety has been significantly improved in modern boilers, too. With updated design features and robust materials, the risk of common issues such as leaks or pressure gauge problems is lower.

Additionally, built-in safety mechanisms help to monitor the boiler's performance and automatically shut the system down if potential dangers are detected.

Upgrading to a modern boiler also means that you're less likely to encounter issues during the winter months, when heating demand is at its peak. Reliability is a crucial aspect of new boilers, helping to prevent unexpected breakdowns and keep your home warm even during the coldest periods.

Of course, while modern boilers are less likely to be plagued by common issues, regular boiler service is still essential. Professional boiler engineers can identify and fix any potential problems early, ensuring that your investment remains in good working order for years to come.

In summary, a new boiler provides many advantages, including energy efficiency, improved performance, enhanced safety, and greater reliability.

By upgrading from an older system, you're not only saving money on your energy bills but also creating a safer and more comfortable environment for everyone within the property.

Pitfalls of Old Boilers

Old boilers can present numerous problems, some of which may pose safety risks or lead to increased energy bills.

One common issue with older boilers is their reliance on a pilot light, which can go out unexpectedly, causing the boiler to stop working. Moreover, pilot lights are less energy efficient compared to modern ignition systems.

Sludge accumulation is another common issue in old boilers. Over time, debris and rust build up in the heating system, forming sludge that can cause blockages and reduce the efficiency of the boiler. This leads to increased energy bills and a higher likelihood of breakdowns.

Old boilers also have a higher risk of carbon monoxide leaks due to the degradation of components, corrosion, and poor maintenance. Carbon monoxide is an odourless and colourless gas that can cause severe health problems or even death. Regular maintenance and inspections can help mitigate this risk, but it's a significant pitfall of older boilers.

Breakdowns are more frequent in old boilers, causing inconvenience and potential hazards. The older the boiler, the more likely it is to experience component failure or corrosion. Additionally, older boilers might have parts that are difficult to source, leading to lengthy repair times.

Energy bills are generally higher with old boilers as they are less efficient than their modern counterparts. Over time, the cost savings of upgrading to a more energy-efficient boiler can outweigh the initial outlay for a new system.

Corrosion, primarily due to ageing components and lack of maintenance, can lead to leaks in the boiler and heating system. This not only reduces the boiler's efficiency but can also cause damage to surrounding structures and require expensive repairs.

Frozen condensate pipes are more common in older boilers, as they may lack sufficient insulation to protect against cold temperatures. This can lead to the boiler shutting down on cold days when it's needed the most. Upgrading to a modern boiler can help avoid this issue.

Finally, old boilers have a slightly higher risk of causing fires due to wear and tear on components, insufficient maintenance, and the potential for gas leaks. It's essential to keep an old boiler well maintained to minimise these risks; however, upgrading to a modern boiler with better safety features and more efficient operation is often the safest and most cost-effective solution.

Safety Precautions and Maintenance

Modern boilers offer increased efficiency and reliable heating solutions for homes, but it's essential to maintain them properly and follow necessary safety precautions.

In this section, we will discuss the role of a heating engineer and the importance of regular maintenance and safety measures to prevent potential hazards.

Role of a Heating Engineer

A heating engineer, also known as a gas safe registered engineer, plays a crucial role in ensuring the safety and efficiency of boilers. They are qualified professionals who can install, maintain, and repair your boiler system. Some key responsibilities of a heating engineer include:

  • Conducting annual service inspections to ensure your boiler is working efficiently and safely

  • Identifying and repairing any leaks in your boiler system

  • Ensuring you meet the warranty requirements by performing regular maintenance checks

  • Installing carbon monoxide detectors to alert homeowners of any potential carbon monoxide poisoning risks

  • Educating homeowners about safety precautions and maintenance guidelines to keep their boiler systems in good working condition

Regular boiler service conducted by a gas safe registered engineer will help you avoid common issues, such as leaks, carbon monoxide poisoning, and a decrease in heating efficiency. Moreover, it extends the lifespan of your boiler, helping you save money on potential boiler cover or replacement costs.

Maintaining your boiler also involves taking some necessary safety precautions. Here's a list of essential safety measures you should follow:

  1. Install a carbon monoxide detector: This device can save lives by alerting you when there's a dangerous build-up of carbon monoxide in your home.

  2. Check for leaks: Regularly inspect your boiler and the surrounding pipework for any signs of leaking.

  3. Ensure proper ventilation: Your boiler needs adequate space and ventilation to function safely; this includes avoiding obstructions around the boiler system.

  4. Know when to replace your boiler: Depending on its type, boilers have a service life of 15-30 years. It's important to consider replacing your boiler once it reaches its service life or shows severe signs of wear and tear.

In conclusion, the safety and maintenance of your boiler system should be a top priority for homeowners. By seeking the services of a heating engineer and following safety precautions, you can ensure the efficient and safe functioning of your modern boiler and protect your home from potential hazards.

Impact on Home Heating Bills


When considering boiler repair or replacement, it is important to assess the impact on home heating bills. Modern boilers are known for their efficiency and can significantly reduce energy bills compared to outdated models.

With the advances in technology and adherence to recent legislation, upgrading to a new boiler can result in cost savings, as well as a more environmentally friendly option.

A modern boiler's efficiency is a key factor in determining the influence on heating bills. Newer models have an efficiency rating of A or B, ensuring optimal energy utilisation. According to the Energy Saving Trust, by upgrading to a more energy-efficient boiler, homeowners can save up to £315 per year on heating costs.

This highlights both the financial benefits and the environmental benefits of investing in a modern boiler, as reduced energy consumption leads to lower carbon emissions.

Warranty and boiler service are also crucial aspects to consider, as they can have a direct impact on the overall cost of maintaining a heating system. A new boiler usually comes with a comprehensive warranty, covering repairs and replacement parts for a certain period.

This protection offers peace of mind to homeowners and can negate unforeseen expenses related to boiler issues. Moreover, regular boiler servicing can ensure optimum performance, prolong the boiler's lifespan and further reduce energy bills.

The boiler's capacity to produce hot water efficiently is another essential factor that affects heating bills. Modern boilers are designed to heat water quickly and maintain a consistent temperature, minimising heat loss. This means that less energy is required to provide a comfortable living environment, which translates into monetary savings.

In addition to energy efficiency, recent legislation has prompted the development of more eco-friendly boilers. One example is the UK's 2025 gas boiler ban, which will affect new housing developments. The introduction of this legislation highlights the vital role of modern boilers in lowering carbon emissions and reducing the environmental impact of home heating systems.

In conclusion, upgrading to a modern boiler has numerous advantages, particularly in terms of impact on home heating bills. Greater efficiency, an extended warranty, better hot water output, adherence to legislation, and eco-friendliness are all factors that contribute towards lower energy bills and a more sustainable heating solution for homeowners.

Legislation and Condition Compliance

When dealing with broken boilers, homeowners and contractors need to consider legislation and compliance with different conditions. One significant legislation to be aware of is the Energy Company Obligation (ECO3).

It provides a framework for assessing broken boilers and determining whether they should be repaired or replaced. Operatives involved in these decisions must meet the competency requirements listed in the boiler-specific section of PAS 2030.

The choice between repair and replacement may sometimes involve a cost-benefit analysis. In the ECO3 checklist, a boiler is assessed economically to determine if it is repairable or needs to be replaced. When a boiler is deemed economically repairable, homeowners can opt for a repair. Otherwise, they might have to consider upgrading to a modern boiler.

In the UK, modern boilers must comply with the Boiler Plus standards, introduced in April 2018.

These standards ensure that households have a reasonable level of choice and control over their heating systems. It is essential to choose a boiler that meets these requirements to achieve energy efficiency and environmental benefits.

Legal protections are also in place for homeowners in case of a botched boiler installation. Under the Consumer Rights Acts (for installations after 1 October 2015) or the Supply of Goods and Services Act (for installations before 1 October 2015), homeowners can argue that there has been a breach of contract if the installation is not up to par. This protection empowers customers to seek the necessary repairs or replacements as warranted by their legal rights.

Additionally, most repairs, replacements, and maintenance work on boilers do not require notifications, except for certain types of replacements - such as combustion appliances, oil tanks, electrical fuse boxes or glazing units. It is crucial to adhere to relevant regulations and ensure proper compliance during the repair or replacement process.

All in all, modern boilers tend to surpass their older counterparts in terms of energy efficiency, performance, and compliance with regulatory standards. Making an informed decision on whether to repair or replace a broken boiler involves considering various aspects, including guarantee, conditions, and legislation.

Homeowners and contractors should keep themselves informed and act responsibly during the boiler repair or replacement process.

Check out our mega guide on New Boiler Costs!

Frequently Asked Questions

Is it better to repair or replace a boiler?

When faced with a broken boiler, it's essential to weigh the cost and benefits of repair versus replacement. Consider factors such as the age of the boiler, the type and frequency of previous repairs, and potential energy savings from a newer, more efficient model. If your boiler is relatively new and the repair is minor, it might be worth repairing. However, if the boiler is older and regularly experiencing issues, replacement may be a more cost-effective solution in the long term.

Is it worth fixing an old boiler?

Older boilers are typically less energy-efficient and may face more frequent issues due to wear and tear. It might be worth repairing an old boiler if the fixes are minor and the unit still has some life left in it. However, if repairs become increasingly frequent and expensive, it may be more economical and environmentally friendly to replace the boiler with a newer, more efficient model.

Is it worth repairing a 10-year-old boiler?

A boiler's life expectancy is usually around 10-15 years, depending on the make and model as well as proper maintenance. If a boiler is 10 years old and requires an expensive repair, it might be more cost-effective to replace it with a new, energy-efficient model. However, if the repair is minor and the boiler is well-maintained, it could be worth repairing.

How much can I save with a new boiler?

A modern boiler can be significantly more energy-efficient than an older model. By installing a new, A-rated boiler, you could save up to 30% on your energy bills. However, individual savings will depend on factors like current boiler efficiency, home insulation, and usage patterns.

Is it more cost-effective to repair or replace a broken boiler?

The decision to repair or replace a broken boiler depends on various factors, including the age and condition of the boiler, the cost and type of repair, and potential energy savings from a new model. In some cases, repairing a single issue could be more cost-effective. However, ongoing repairs or expensive fixes might make replacement a smarter choice.

How do boiler efficiency ratings affect my decision?

Boiler efficiency ratings help to provide a clearer picture of a unit's energy performance. The higher the efficiency rating, the more energy the boiler can convert into heat, resulting in lower energy bills. When considering repairing or replacing a broken boiler, it's important to compare efficiency ratings of your current system with potential new models to determine the potential savings and long-term cost-effectiveness.

What are the benefits of a combi boiler?

Combi boilers are an increasingly popular choice for homeowners. They offer several benefits, including instant hot water supply, reduced energy consumption, and space-saving design. Additionally, combi boilers eliminate the need for separate hot water storage cylinders, simplifying the installation process and reducing maintenance needs.

Why is regular boiler maintenance important?

Regular boiler maintenance is crucial for ensuring the longevity and efficiency of your boiler. By scheduling annual boiler check-ups and servicing, you can help prevent small issues from becoming larger problems, save on energy bills, and extend the life of your boiler. Proper maintenance can also ensure your boiler's safety by detecting potential hazards such as gas leaks or faulty parts.

Stephen Day profile photo
Article by
Stephen Day | Co-founder
Gas Safe registered and FGAS certified engineer with over 20 years experience in the heating and cooling industry.